I found his observations not bad more the manner of writing reviews. I would have given the cold one a 4/5 because its a good chariot with a bit of staying power. 5/5 I would reserve for must takes. However after reading the book multiple times I don't see this kind of unit yet (good thing). I love the scourgerunner model and its rules but I can see why it isn't as good in a competitive environment. Its a weak chariot with D6 strength 4 impact hits and 2 strength 4 attacks it won''t affect combat much. Chariots can't march so out maneuvering a monster is hard. M9 can do it but you will probably hit only on a 5+ (long range and move to fire). Thats not reliable to trick a monster. And its not really cheap either. However this is not gonna stop me from playing it