sirrouga
11-22-2009, 01:34 PM
Through a combined effort of boredom, insomnia, and random curiosity I went through all the sets GW offers to see which ones are great deals and which ones are just meh. I'm pretty sure this has been done but this is including many different sets and some of which are unavailable. I looked at all the battle forces, strike forces, and even that crazy spear box. Using the prices listed on the GW site on 7/24/2009, I done this a while back and posted it elsewhere, figure I bring it here so more can see it.
In many cases, a different amount of models are given in the battleforce than what would be available from a standard box, in such cases factions are used. For example, Berserkers come in 12 packs while the Chaos Marine battleforce only has 8 berserkers in it thus I used 2/3 of the price of the berserker set. Also, this is just using base costs; not figuring in taxes, shipping, crazy people, etc so your price and saving may vary.
Lets start with the largest category, the battle forces! ($90 - $95 price range)
Starting with the best deal and going down to the worst
Dark Eldar Battleforce Saves you $56.75
Old Tyranids Battleforce Saves you $55 (Box no longer listed on GW's site)
Tau Empire Battleforce Saves you $55
Necron Battleforce Saves you $51.66
Dark Angel Ravenwing Battleforce Saves you $47.50
Chaos Space Marines Battleforce Saves you $41.50
Space Marine Battleforce Saves you $41.50
Imperial Guard Battleforces Saves you $34 (Both Cadian and Catachan sets cost the same)
Space Wolves Battleforce Saves you $30
Eldar Battleforce Saves you $26.25
Ork Battleforce Saves you $25.25
Now the next category up to examine are the larger sets; strike forces, mega forces, and phalanx! ($175 - $279 price range)
Once again starting with the best deal and going down to the worst
Old Necron Warrior Phalanx saves you $130.00 (Box no longer listed on GW's site)
Chaos Space Marine Renegade Strike Force Saves you $116.75
Old Space Marine Strike Force Saves you $81 (Box no longer listed on GW's site)
Ork Mega Force Saves you $69.75
Old Chaos Daemon Spearhead Saves you $60.75 (Box no longer listed on GW's site)
Space Marine Mega Force Saves you $58.75
And our final category of the night and it has only one entry. The giant mega box army set! (The $1066.75 price range)
The Spear of Sicarius Saves you...... $0.00
That is right ladies and gentlemen, the biggest and most expensive box set from GW saves you nothing. Not a single cent for you!
Some special nods...
Dark Eldar is the only battle force that includes some terrain.
Chaos Marines, Space Marines, and the Tau Empire battle forces contain 5 different boxes of units in them while the rest only have 4.
Chaos Daemons, Daemon Hunters, Witch Hunters, Black Templar, and Blood Angels do not have battle forces.
The Chaos Daemons Spearhead is the only set that includes its army codex.
The Eldar and Tyranid battle forces are the only ones that include a Heavy Support option.
Chaos Marine and Tau Empire Battle forces are the only ones that include an Elite option (The Tau even has 2 Elites!)
I will update this post with new sets if there is interest. If I missed a set or two please let me know and I will get them included. I realize that many of these sets are no longer available but many local stores still have some (my local game store still has a few chaos daemon spearheads!).
::Edits History::
Added notes on which sets are old and out of print.
Added the Dark Angel Ravenwing Battleforce
In many cases, a different amount of models are given in the battleforce than what would be available from a standard box, in such cases factions are used. For example, Berserkers come in 12 packs while the Chaos Marine battleforce only has 8 berserkers in it thus I used 2/3 of the price of the berserker set. Also, this is just using base costs; not figuring in taxes, shipping, crazy people, etc so your price and saving may vary.
Lets start with the largest category, the battle forces! ($90 - $95 price range)
Starting with the best deal and going down to the worst
Dark Eldar Battleforce Saves you $56.75
Old Tyranids Battleforce Saves you $55 (Box no longer listed on GW's site)
Tau Empire Battleforce Saves you $55
Necron Battleforce Saves you $51.66
Dark Angel Ravenwing Battleforce Saves you $47.50
Chaos Space Marines Battleforce Saves you $41.50
Space Marine Battleforce Saves you $41.50
Imperial Guard Battleforces Saves you $34 (Both Cadian and Catachan sets cost the same)
Space Wolves Battleforce Saves you $30
Eldar Battleforce Saves you $26.25
Ork Battleforce Saves you $25.25
Now the next category up to examine are the larger sets; strike forces, mega forces, and phalanx! ($175 - $279 price range)
Once again starting with the best deal and going down to the worst
Old Necron Warrior Phalanx saves you $130.00 (Box no longer listed on GW's site)
Chaos Space Marine Renegade Strike Force Saves you $116.75
Old Space Marine Strike Force Saves you $81 (Box no longer listed on GW's site)
Ork Mega Force Saves you $69.75
Old Chaos Daemon Spearhead Saves you $60.75 (Box no longer listed on GW's site)
Space Marine Mega Force Saves you $58.75
And our final category of the night and it has only one entry. The giant mega box army set! (The $1066.75 price range)
The Spear of Sicarius Saves you...... $0.00
That is right ladies and gentlemen, the biggest and most expensive box set from GW saves you nothing. Not a single cent for you!
Some special nods...
Dark Eldar is the only battle force that includes some terrain.
Chaos Marines, Space Marines, and the Tau Empire battle forces contain 5 different boxes of units in them while the rest only have 4.
Chaos Daemons, Daemon Hunters, Witch Hunters, Black Templar, and Blood Angels do not have battle forces.
The Chaos Daemons Spearhead is the only set that includes its army codex.
The Eldar and Tyranid battle forces are the only ones that include a Heavy Support option.
Chaos Marine and Tau Empire Battle forces are the only ones that include an Elite option (The Tau even has 2 Elites!)
I will update this post with new sets if there is interest. If I missed a set or two please let me know and I will get them included. I realize that many of these sets are no longer available but many local stores still have some (my local game store still has a few chaos daemon spearheads!).
::Edits History::
Added notes on which sets are old and out of print.
Added the Dark Angel Ravenwing Battleforce